Home Blog

Nvidia’s tutorial on genuine good governance, needed by tech bros and governistas alike



Charles de Gaulle said, “The graveyards are filled with indispensable men.” That rings especially true despite the pathetic cries of the ‘Bring Jensen Back’ bros.

Nvidia’s strong earnings release today proves once and for all that Nvidia does not need Jensen Huang to return to flourish as a strong American national champion. Interim CEO Colette Kress deftly raised forecasts moving forward, pointing to the underlying strength of the business, which is far greater than any one individual, while winning plaudits for running the earnings call with command, presence, and impressive candor. And indeed, new board chair Harvey Jones definitely closed the door on Jensen Huang’s return as CEO amidst news that the SEC is now probing Huang and Nvidia.

All this makes the unresolved governance questions and lessons from the Nvidia debacle even more important.

In the aftermath of Jensen Huang’s ouster from Nvidia this week, a tiny band of tech bros, perhaps intoxicated by their own sudden wealth and prominence, have cast good governance principles to the wind by unrealistically advocating for the return of Jensen Huang, decrying the “woke” politically correct management policies which they believe led to Huang’s exit. At the same time, a chorus of finger-pointing good governance advocates has joined the fray, throwing every pet theory of organizational structure and regulatory restraints on risk-seeking entrepreneurs. Both camps ignore the real collapse of board oversight, which is the tragically poor judgement of the CEO matched with the faulty character and faulty process of board oversight and not its clunky bureaucratic mechanics.

The tech bro cheerleaders rooted for a messianic return of Huang, despite the ongoing investigations into his wide array of apparently corrupt actions and character collapses, such as his blatant violations of Nvidia’s code of conduct and unresolved national security concerns. The arrogant, naïve fantasies in the chants of these tech bros is encapsulated by Telegram founder Pavel Durov’s X post declaring, “Jensen made a rookie mistake. He had a board”, apparently forgetting that any executive who is entrusted with other people’s money owes a fiduciary duty to their shareholders first, above their own self-enrichment. They are happy to snag the money but then to dodge accountability.

Then, on the other end of the critics’ spectrum, good governance advocates, self-declared governistas, have rushed to offer a smattering of bad solutions for Nvidia’s governance woes. These proposed solutions are as ludicrous as they are trite, and as irrelevant as they are ineffectual.

For example, Charlie Elson at the University of Delaware somehow baselessly managed to blame a favorite bogeyman of many governistas, dual-class shares, for Nvidia’s woes — even though Nvidia has a single-class stock structure and not dual-class shares at all, a rather inconvenient fact which nevertheless did not detract from Elson launching into his tiring tirades. Elson bewilderingly argued in Directors & Boards that “in the end, this may spark, and I hope it does, a real reconsideration of the whole notion of dual-class stock in publicly traded companies”, as if that would be a panacea for all of Nvidia’s board woes, an argument which The New York Times also haplessly repeated.

Similarly, governance professor Richard LeBlanc of York University proposed an independent chair as the panacea to all Nvidia’s governance woes, even though Nvidia already had an independent lead director who was the former CEO of Cooley Law Firm, Stephen Neal.

All of these proposed governista solutions are irrelevant cliches offering insufficient and misguided recipes.

Between clumsy New York Times op-eds, delusional Silicon Valley social media campaigns, and even an ideologically charged, anti-management Delaware Chancery Court judge, it appears that both anti-oversight tech bros and scolding governistas need to relearn some basic lessons about corporate board diligence.

Here’s what these self-anointed governance experts miss and what the real lessons for boards from the Nvidia crisis are:

  • Don’t build your business on other people’s money and then later resent accountability to them
  • Don’t fall for mindless metrics which miss the actual process of governance — much like the way the “Goodhart’s Law” of economics warns over confusing the metric with the underlying phenomena
  • Don’t confuse capital structure, whether dual-class shares or single class shares, as indicators of board caliber, board culture, and genuine independence
  • Don’t fall victim to vague admonitions over “good faith” as genuine definitions of proper board diligence.
  • Don’t rely on your accountants and attorneys to protect you – as the buck stops with you.

The checklist fallacy that ISS, Glass Lewis, and many good governance advocates have fallen into

All of the misguided proposed solutions from governistas tend to draw from the same wrongheaded playbook that ISS and Glass Lewis have preached for decades, recited on cue by the governistas: split the chair and CEO roles, encourage more so-called independent board members, tally the committees, and count board diversity. As we have argued in Fortune, this tired and trite playbook has never been able to tell a good board from a bad one.

Consider how Nvidia was an ISS and Glass Lewis box-checker’s showpiece. Every director but Huang was technically independent. It had an independent lead director who was a former CEO of a respected law firm; independent audit, compensation and governance committees and committee chairs; annual elections for every board position without any staggered terms; and the ‘one vote per share’ principle so beloved by governistas. Huang was not even chairman of his own board: Nvidia had no chairman at all until he left, so Nvidia even fit the technical separation of roles box with a separate lead independent director. In June, shareholders re-elected all ten directors, the CEO with 99% of the vote, with ISS supporting the entire director slate this year, as it has each year for many years now.

But the Nvidia crisis reminds us all just how misleading are the metrics of ISS and Glass Lewis’ checklist. This ‘check-the-box’ approach does absolutely nothing to actually weed out genuinely responsible boards from boards asleep at the switch operating on a bedraggled autopilot. Indeed, it is ironic that many of the worst corporate governance crises this century have been at companies which were darlings of the governista community.

For example, Enron had 12 independent directors among its 14 directors, split the chairman and CEO roles in its final year, and had a former dean of Stanford’s business school, an accounting professor, chairing its audit committee, winning widespread praise from governance advocates with one governance publication even naming the Enron board one of America’s five best boards in 2000 – right before Enron blew up, exposed as a fraud. Similarly, Silicon Valley Bank had an independent chair and a board that was entirely independent other than its CEO, and 10 of Lehman Brothers’ 11 directors were independent.

Indeed, when Stanford researchers tested ISS’s then-flagship governance rating against five measures of how companies actually fared, including restatements, shareholder lawsuits and stock performance, they found no significant correlation with any of them.

The first author wrote in Harvard Business Review in 2002, “In the wake of the meltdowns of such once great companies as Adelphia, Enron, Tyco, and WorldCom, enormous attention has been focused on the companies’ boards … And yet a close examination of those boards reveals no broad pattern of incompetence or corruption. In fact, the boards followed most of the accepted standards for board operations: Members showed up for meetings; they had lots of personal money invested in the company; audit committees, compensation committees, and codes of ethics were in place; the boards weren’t too small, too big, too old, or too young.”

Alas, the reliance upon such banal bromides of supposed good governance, lead to the recitation of platitudes in publications but worse yet miss the targeted need entirely – much the way the Goodhart’s Law of economics warns us to not confuse the metrics of the tool with the assessment of the underlying phenomena itself. This is also parallel to intelligence testing, where the test is an indicator of performance against the unidimensional artificial metrics of the intelligence test as an instrument itself and misses the many other untested dimensions of intelligence as Harvard psychologist Howard Gardner has pointed out in his classic Frames of Mind analysis.

The dual-class red herring

Another favorite bogeyman of the governance community tends to be dual-class shares, and this long-held bias is once again rearing its ugly head with governance commentators rushing to blame dual-class shares for the Nvidia crisis – even though, ironically and inconveniently, Nvidia only has one class of stock, and Nvidia has never actually had dual-class shares at all.

Indeed, ISS now generally universally recommends against directors at companies with unequal voting rights, without exception, reflecting how widely held this erroneous strain of thinking is entrenched in some circles of the governance community.

By way of full disclosure, we are sometimes wrongly identified as an ‘advocate for dual-class structures’, in the words of Vice Chancellor Travis Laster of the Delaware Chancery Court, who has been overturned by the Delaware Supreme Court no less than 35 times in his idiosyncratic and tortured readings of the law.

But we are not the universal dual-class share advocate Laster misleadingly portrays us as. Our view is much more nuanced and captured in the conclusion of my Harvard Law Corporate Governance Forum piece: “In evaluating the outperformance of dual-class shares and in evaluating common scenarios where dual-class shares work especially well, balanced against common pitfalls, the evidence is clear that for companies, there is no single right answer between dual-class, multi-class, or single-class shares. It is all situational, dependent on a company’s circumstances, the demonstrated caliber of their leadership, and the environment in which they operate. Just as dual-class shares are not the right structure for all companies; dual-class shares can make sense for certain companies, in certain scenarios. These crucial nuances are often lost in what has increasingly become the single-minded zealotry of ‘one share, one vote’ advocates, seeking to impose single class structures on all companies irrespective of circumstance.”

Indeed, what critics of dual-class shares like Laster and Elson miss is that some of the worst corporate collapses and frauds of the modern era had ‘one share, one vote’ share structures, ranging from Enron, Worldcom, Tyco, Arthur Andersen, Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, Wirecard, FTX, Silicon Valley Bank, and First Republic Bank, all of which share a single commonality: they did not have dual-class shares. Thus, critics like Charlie Elson who blame dual-class shares for Nvidia’s woes are committing the sin of governance by non sequitur. It is like prosecuting a car company for making potential getaway cars for a robbery which was actually committed on foot. Clearly, a formula that indiscriminately, automatically scores Berkshire Hathaway’s share structure as a vice and Nvidia’s as a virtue, without human discernment or space for an iota of discretion, is measuring based on the wrong yardstick.

What actually failed at Nvidia, and what it reveals about governista blind spots

What failed at Nvidia was not any of the factors identified above; rather, it was the caliber of the directors and the culture amongst the board that proved problematic.

As the first author wrote in the seminal Harvard Business Review article in 2002, ‘What Makes Great Boards Great’, great boards are social systems before they are governance structures. They build enough trust that management brings bad news early, with open and candid discussions and no secrets kept. Great boards treat dissent as a duty, and promote cultures where questioning authority is not only welcome but expected. They rotate roles so that no director is typecast as a permanent cheerleader or scold.

As my former colleague, the former Yale School of Management Dean and former SEC Chairman Bill Donaldson said at a Yale CEO Summit many years ago, “On the subject of board governance… corporate governance has become a cottage industry with lots of opportunists, and there’s some very superficial thought out there about what a board really is…..The least examined is that it is a social entity. It has human beings on it. Nobody talks much about that. Everybody says, ‘Oh, you ought to have certain people on the audit committee because they’ll be independent, etc., etc.’

“There hasn’t been nearly enough work done on the social contract on the board and the recognition of what is really going on, on that board. And a lot of times, what’s really going on bears the seeds of horror stories. Perhaps there’s a group that’s aligned improperly, and that group dominates either through tenure on the board or whatever and allows bad things to go on because nobody really recognizes what those interpersonal relationships are.”

Donaldson emphasized that great boards hold each director accountable and grade their own performance as hard as the CEO’s, and this gets to the caliber of the board as well as the culture of the board. None of this works without directors of the stature to look a monarch in the eye. As I wrote in The Hero’s Farewell, monarchs are larger than life CEOs who would leave office only by death or palace revolt. With a visionary founder, a board’s job is to retain and contain: keep the genius, check the hubris.

But Nvidia’s board lacked the stature to contain or check Huang’s impulses; they could only retain and worship. Evaluating the board members individually, no Nvidia director has ever run an S&P 500 company and none has national security experience, at a company whose chips are a national security asset. Industry peers Microsoft, IBM, and Dell each have at least four current and former big-company CEOs on their board; Nvidia had none. And apparently, the board was asleep at the switch on succession planning, which is one of the primary functions of a board. Nobody thought to groom even an emergency successor for a CEO with more than 60 direct reports and no president or chief operating officer beneath him, and a system of doing business through handshake deals to centralize all power in himself. And when the crisis came, the board’s first instinct was to vouch for him before its own investigation had begun before finally surrendering to the facts of the situation.

Similarly, it was plainly inadequate and insufficient for Nvidia’s board, to simply defer to the professional judgment of their advisors, such as their external accountant PwC or their external law firm Cooley. PwC signed off on financial reports with what many experts consider to be questionable accounting, obfuscating the geographic origins of Nvidia’s revenues and the end users of sensitive Nvidia chips in ways that could possibly open the board up to legal claims of failure of oversight if not even perhaps fraud in the eyes of many experts.

Even today, there still seems to be a latent expectation amongst some in tech circles, including apparently from Huang himself, that a weak Nvidia board will just collapse and bring Huang back in deference to the founder if enough pressure is brought to bear. Huang himself put out an unusual statement this morning, saying that “If the Board of Directors decides that my return is in the best interest of our shareholders, our employees, the company, and America, I would be honored to answer these calls and return as CEO”, even though Huang is now the target of no less than 4 ongoing government investigations across congressional oversight hearings and federal probes as well as multiple shareholder lawsuits. Certainly, Marshal Philippe Petain of Vichy France; the deposed Emperor Napoleon, Enron’s disgraced Jeff Skilling, Worldcom’s deposed Bernie Ebbers, and other deposed monarchs dragged out kicking and screaming would have likewise enthusiastically volunteered to return after being thrown out by their constituents. Bewilderingly, even some proxy ratings firms like Egan Jones seem to be lending implicit support to the ‘Bring Jensen Back’ movement, declaring that “It is not entirely clear the board acted in the best interest of shareholders” by removing Huang, looking past the evasion of sanctions, national security, and accounting integrity concerns to say the board should not have removed Jensen on the basis of shareholder returns from prior, possibly misleading financial reports.

Lessons for boards moving forward – especially in working with a strong founder

What Nvidia’s board woes highlight is that contrary to the outdated ideas of some – for example, how Travis Laster would define ‘good faith’ as checking hot tempers at the door – the measure of genuine board diligence is the willingness to foster board cultures of open dissent and genuine partnership with CEOs over blind deference.

The latter challenge is especially salient when it comes to working with larger-than-life founders. The right answer is not for boards to go to war with these creative geniuses by trying to suppress them, or to lose trust by trying to fire them over foot faults. Rather, it is up to the board to develop governance practices that show they know how to partner with the genius they are privileged to have among them.

The boards of Microsoft, Amazon, Dell, Starbucks and, ultimately, Apple figured out how to work with Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, Michael Dell, Howard Schultz and Steve Jobs, forging alignment between the needs of their founder visionary CEOs and the shareholders. These boards helped their founders appreciate and address their human frailties, whether with non-accusatory accountability (as with Gates through Microsoft anti-trust litigation) or during health crises (Jobs’ battle with cancer and need for credible succession plan).

It is not easy to regulate genius and creative founders do not resemble rational people as they challenge the daunting odds of success that most people wisely avoid. They are also often obsessed and single minded about their visions – which seem to many to be delusions seeking a mirage of unattainable entrepreneurial success. Yet their innovations can disrupt and transform society on the few occasions where they succeed.

Sigmund Freud reminded us that society is changed by its discontents. Painter Robert Motherwell confessed that as an artist there is never satisfaction, because creative joy is mixed with the anguish of what could be. But at the same time, boards must recognize that they are not dealing with an artist painting in a private studio on their own canvas, but rather an artist who is using other people’s resources, painting on a public canvas, and so must listen to other voices.

Only by forging genuine partnerships with their CEO built on trust and mutual candor, can boards strike the right balance between blind deference and overbearing suffocation, particularly when it comes to working with bigger-than-life visionary founders. The lesson for boards, and what both sides of the critics’ spectrum misses, is that the solution is not related to the structure of the board; rather, it is the professional courage to do their jobs fully, and nobody can legislate performance through checklists or rulebooks.

The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary pieces are solely the views of their authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.

The Stock Market Is Being Used as a Dumping Ground



Thank you to Bilt for sponsoring this video! Start earning rewards on rent and mortgage payments when you sign up at

SpaceX went public in June at $1.77 trillion, OpenAI and Anthropic are next in line, and together the three are worth more than every tech IPO in America since 1980 combined.

Companies used to go public to start growing. Now they go public once they’re done growing.

In this video, I’ll break down:
• How 3 companies are worth more than 45 years of tech IPOs combined.
• Why the main reasons companies used to go public stopped working.
• How a law meant to help young companies go public backfired.
• How private markets quietly replaced public markets.
• Why companies go public in the first place, and why so few still do.

👉 I post everyday here:

All illustrations, visuals, and animations in this video are original and hand-drawn by a freelance artist.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this video and on this channel (collectively, the “Content”) is for informational, educational, and entertainment purposes only and does not constitute investment, financial, legal, or tax advice, nor a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security or investment strategy. Investing involves risk and you must do your own research. Nothing in the Content should be interpreted as creating a fiduciary relationship, financial advisory relationship, or client relationship of any kind. The host, the channel, and all affiliated entities expressly disclaim any and all liability for any direct or consequential loss or damage arising directly or indirectly from the use of, reliance upon, or interpretation of the Content. By viewing or interacting with the Content, you acknowledge and agree to these terms and release the host and all related parties from any and all claims related to your reliance on the information provided.

source

Are “Equity Millionaires” Stopping the Housing Market from Sinking?


Dave:
Almost two and a half million mortgage holders in the US now have at least a million dollars in home equity, but at the same time, more than a million borrowers are underwater on their mortgage. Those two numbers come from the same brand new ICE mortgage monitor and they tell very different stories about today’s market. So today in the show, we’re having Andy Walden from ICE back to walk us through where that equity sits, why cash out borrowing and adjustable rate loans are rising, and whether growing distress in some markets could turn into opportunities for investors. I’m Dave Meyer. This is On the Market. Let’s get to it. Andy, welcome back to On the Market. Thanks for being here.

Andy:
Appreciate you having me. Good to see you again.

Dave:
Yeah, it’s a good time to have you here. It feels to me in just the last couple of weeks, there has been a shift in the housing market. Are you noticing the same thing?

Andy:
Yeah. I mean, I think anytime you see mortgage rates get up into the high sixes, low sevens, you start to see things cool off and you start to see a little bit different dynamic when you look across the country. It’s not as much one size fits all. You see some markets gaining, some markets losing, and so you’re certainly moving into a different environment than we have been in the last few years.

Dave:
Is there something magical about 7%? Is it psychological or is there actually some affordability threshold that we’re bumping up against?

Andy:
Mathematically, it works the same as every different number, but there is a psychological component and you can see it in the data. If we run a stack of where borrowers have taken out interest rates over the last few years, there is a large spike right at 6.875, 6.95, 6.99%. Really? Folks want to have a six in the front of their loan, and I mean they can do that a couple different ways. You can either wait and see or folks will buy down their interest rate to get into the high sixes when you get into the low sevens. But there is a psychological component to having a rate that has a six in the front and when you get close to six to having a five in the front. So everybody wants that slightly lower rate.

Dave:
Well, feel free to disagree, but it doesn’t feel to me like rates are going to get into the sixes, at least on average without a buy down for the standard 30-year fixed rate mortgage, at least in the next couple of months. I don’t see a path to that. So I’m curious, well, first if you agree, and if so, what does that mean for the housing market this winter?

Andy:
Yeah, I mean we’ll see in terms of will we get there? We’ve teased on it, touched on it. If you look at 10 years that are kind of that primary subcomponent of mortgage rates, so there’s typically a 2% difference between what you get in a 10-year and what you get in a 30-year rate. Those 10 years have dropped down into the high fours over the last week to two weeks, especially after the election, which if you put a typical 2% spread on top of that would get you into the high sixes. And so we’ve been at a point from a 10-year environment that you can see a 6% rate. The challenge is that those spreads have widened out a little bit because there’s a little bit more caution around the volatility and where we go from here from a geopolitical perspective. So it’s possible we could see it.
If you look at the baseline forecast, we were just in New York talking to some of our big clients there and the primary consensus was high six, low 7% rate for the near future. It’s contingent on a lot of different things from a macroeconomic perspective. So we’ll see how some of those larger things play out, but that’s the baseline view is kind of in the range that we’re in right now for the near future.

Dave:
Just the data in the last couple of weeks, we’ve seen pending sales drop, we’ve seen actual transactions drop. We’re starting to see increases in cancellations. Do you think that was a temporary reaction? We always see some slowdowns before elections or is this kind of the new normal where we’re going to see even lower transaction volume even though we’ve had really low transaction volume for four years now?

Andy:
Yeah, I mean I think it’s some of both. When you typically look at how applications following interest rate increases, you tend to see a temporary reprieve and it tends to be the less serious buyers that pull out of the market first, you see fewer conversions to close. But I mean there is a ratio that you tend to see around interest rate movement and the number of sales that tend to take place, this one to eight ratio where if rates rise a percent, you tend to see an 8% decline in the number of sales taking place out there in the market. So there is some reality to rates going up and it constraining some borrowers out there in the market and pulling back some demand. But outside of that, you’re still seeing some decent demand, all things considered out there in the market right now and your lock volumes and your pull through rates holding up a little bit better than your applications are.

Dave:
Okay. It’s a good, I wouldn’t want to say optimistic, but a very sober view of what’s going on. It just makes a lot of sense. But it does feel like pressure, at least downward pressure on pricing is increasing. I don’t know if you saw this, but Redfin said that the other day. I know you keep a different data set that still says that home prices are positive right now. But it was the first time I’ve seen in quite a while people saying nominal home prices are down. Do you think we’re trending in that direction generally at least on a national basis?

Andy:
Yeah, I think if you see that high six, low 7%, that’s roughly what’s been happening in our data as well. We got as high as a 1.4% growth this summer, it’s back down to 1%. So you’re seeing things soften up and when you look at seasonally adjusted month over month gains, you’ve certainly seen those soften up as well. So certainly in the rate range where you are right now, again, you’re going to see a split market where some areas of the country, your Midwest, your Northeast are going to continue to see price growth, but those softer areas of the country that have kind of been teetering on price growth are roughly flat, you’ll see some of those move negative.

Dave:
I’ve said on the show and believe generally that we have a lot of the ingredients for a modest correction where prices go down a little bit. But the question everyone wants to know, I’m sure you get this all the time, is does it get worse? Does it turn into a crash? And one of the things I love about the ICE mortgage monitor is it dives really into the health of the credit side of the housing market. So maybe you could fill us in a little bit about what’s going on and if there is any concerning rise in the level of distress in the market.

Andy:
Yeah. I mean, I think when you look at delinquencies overall, we’ve been in a very low delinquency, very low default, very low foreclosure world for the better part of the last few years by design. There was a lot of intent and focus around the mortgage industry of making sure that because of all of the things in and around the COVID pandemic that folks weren’t losing their home to foreclosure. So we went into very, very low delinquency rates. You started to see those trend higher kind of gradually, especially among overall delinquency rates.You’re slowly seeing those tick up over the last couple of years. They’re still well below long run averages. The areas that I think catch your eye a little bit more are the serious delinquency front. They’re up about 20% from the same time last year. A lot of that happened in Q4 last year, Q1 this year, and have kind of leveled off since then.
So if you look at new inflow of serious defaults out there in the market, they’re actually slightly down actually from where they were at the same time last year. So we’re actually seeing some positive news there. But in terms of overall foreclosure activity, I do think you’ll continue to gradually see that normalize after some record low years here. We’ve started to see foreclosure starts trend a little bit higher, active foreclosure inventories back to pre-pandemic levels now. Sales like foreclosure completions actually taking place are still at a third of the levels you traditionally see out there in the market. But I think as things work their way through the pipeline, you’ll gradually see those normalize as well. But in terms of broader concern or risk, there’s not a whole lot of red flags kind of flashing from a credit perspective or a default perspective in today’s market.

Dave:
That’s reassuring to hear because when you do hear the, at least I see these things on social media or the news like foreclosures are up 80% year over year, whatever the number is. It’s like there’s a base effect here where it was from an artificial low. So it’s important to remember for everyone, one, that we are coming from an artificial low and two, the distress and foreclosure cycle is long. And so yes, certain parts of it are going to increase based on what happened a year ago. But as Andy said, new inflows, people who are going into serious delinquency their first time is actually relatively stable right now. It’s not like the bottom is necessarily falling out. And you said a lot of it started Q4, Q1 last year. Did something happen? Was there some catalyst for that?

Andy:
Yeah. So a lot of what you’re seeing is centered around the FHA market and a rise in serious delinquencies among FHA loans, which tend to serve the lower credit score, lower down payment community in the market. They shifted away from, as we were talking about earlier, they’re kind of COVID era loss mitigation programs into a more sustainable long run loss mitigation program there. And because of that, it limits how frequently borrowers can receive permanent workouts on their loans. It puts in some regulations around trial payment plans and those types of things. And so because of that, you saw a shift in performance that happened right around that time as well. It happened relatively quickly, again, kind of Q4, Q1 last year and has settled out since then. So again, I think that’s where context is key around this when you start to look at, all right, is there a broader concern around default risk in that FHA community itself?
If so, you’d be looking at things like rising new defaults coming out of that group. And that’s not what you see. You actually see fewer new defaults than there were at this point last year, fewer re-defaults there as well. So it’s one of those situations where two things can be true at the same time. Yes, you’re seeing a large jump from the same time last year, but if you look at it in a shorter term window of, okay, what’s actually happened in the last six months, you’ve started to see some of that activity settle back out and us move more towards a new normal in that space.

Dave:
Yeah. I mean, I was looking in the ICE mortgage monitor at a very nice chart. We’ll put it up on the screen for anyone watching on YouTube, but just showing delinquency rates by loan type. And you see FHA, it was going up. I actually called it out on the show, I think it was in the spring, something to watch, but it’s kind of stabilized. But the thing that hasn’t, it looks like VA loans for veterans kinds of loans are in a, at least looks like a concerning trajectory right now.

Andy:
It’s certainly an area to watch. And I say all that earlier, not to say that there aren’t any areas of focus for the mortgage market. There certainly are, right? Negative equity and the combination of negative equity and serious delinquency is I think something that the market needs to keep a close eye on. The VA trajectory is something worth watching as well. Again, when you look at new default inflow there, you’re starting to see it rise year over year. You’re seeing fewer cures out of serious delinquency on that VA side as well. And obviously that’s not a good combination for a market. And so I think VA is going to be the next topic of conversation out there. I think it’s going to take over what you’re hearing on the FHA side. So that is an area to watch. GSE, which serves the overwhelming majority of the market, you’re seeing some modest growth and new default activity there as well.
Again, nothing concerning, especially since we’re coming off record low rates, but some modest rise there as well. So I do think you’ll see serious delinquency foreclosure activity continue to trend up into the right towards a normalization path. But again, more yellow flags in the market, things to watch, subcomponents of the market to watch, but nothing overly concerning overall.

Dave:
And as Andy said, GSEs, which stands for government sponsored entities, which is basically Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, they handle the majority of mortgages. Andy, just for context for our audience, we’re talking about some distress in FHA and VA. What percentage of the total mortgage market do those types of loans make up?

Andy:
It’s about a quarter of the total market between the two. FHA is roughly 15%. VA’s about 7%. They tend to be on the lower end of the credit spectrum, so you’re more entry level borrowers. They tend to be lower down payment as well. And so when you start to look at shifts in home prices and negative equity and those types of things, those types of loans tend to move towards the forefront just because it takes less price movement to move those borrowers underwater and they tend to become delinquent at a little bit higher rate than what you see in the GLC loans.

Dave:
All right everyone, we got to take a quick break, but we’ll be back with Andy Walden right after this. Welcome back to On the Market. I’m here talking to Andy Walden from ICE. Let’s jump back in. Andy, I’m curious what in the data, what would it take in the data for you to get nervous that we’re going to see significant price declines? What would be a red flag for you?

Andy:
Yeah, it is a good question. I think that’s something the market grapples with all the time. What is normal? What should this look like? I mean, if we saw a massive surge in new default activity out there in the market, if I saw a big rise in unemployment that was driving a lot of this, obviously the key component of whether you’re able to continue to make your mortgage payment is do you have a job? Do you have that monthly inflow? So if we saw a rise in delinquencies that wasn’t program oriented, that wasn’t something that shifted in guidelines in the market, but it was more dictated by a true rise in unemployment and borrowers really shifting their monthly cash flows and not being able to meet some of these obligations, I think that would be concerning. If we saw foreclosure sales and losses start to sharply rise, I think that would be more concerning.
So it’s not to say that we’re not keeping a close eye on all the things going on right now, but they’re just not tipping that lever of extreme concern.

Dave:
For those people out there who are feeling nervous about the housing market, either that it’s going to crash or they recognize even that it’s in their local market, it’s just a weak market. Can you help us understand in what ways the current environment is similar and also dissimilar from the last time we saw home prices go down, which was around the great financial crisis?

Andy:
I think similar in terms of equity positions and recent home price growth and similar in terms of home prices versus underlying income levels. I think those are the similarities. What it’s built on and how it was built is very different. So the underlying credit quality of the mortgage market today, the health of homeowners, again, just the quality of folks that have these mortgages out there is very, very different. So if you look at how home prices rose in 2024, 25, 26, it was stated income, stated loans, it was 0% down, negative amortized, all of those products that we know were out in the market that allowed you to buy a lot more home than your underlying income would allow you to support. This time around, home prices were built on a low interest rate environment that allowed you to buy a lot more home than you traditionally would be able to buy in your home.
The difference is what happens from here? So when you look back at 2005, six, seven, eight, those lower quality loans that failed brought down that financial system and brought down home prices. This time around, you don’t have that low credit quality segment out there in the market. And what having those home prices built on lower interest rate did is it also locked a lot of those homeowners in place so that when interest rates rise and your demand side pulls back a little bit, your supply side pulls back at the same time. And so I think when interest rates rose in 2022, a lot of folks said, okay, here goes the housing market and you’re going to see prices come down just considerably here over the next couple of years. And what happened was sellers are kind of pulling back at the same time buyers are pulling back.
So rates rise and they both pull back at the same time. Rates come down and that loosens up inventory at the same time it loosens up some demand. And so it’s resulting in a longer flatter normalization of the housing market than what you saw last time around.

Dave:
Well, I think you called that. I think it was like a year and a half ago you were on and talking about a return to affordability and how it doesn’t need to be a sharp price correction, that there’s some combination of rates, prices, real wage growth that can eventually restore affordability to the market. It just takes time, which is frustrating, I would say.

Andy:
And we’ve been moving down the path for the last three years. We continue to gradually move in the right direction. And I think that’s probably best case for the housing market rather than seeing a big price decline where you start to see borrowers move underwater, especially as we’ve gotten a couple years down and borrowers have now a significant number of homeowners have homes that they’ve purchased at or near current levels, it could be detrimental to see prices drop quickly. So that longer term correction, even though it’s painful over time, is probably the better way to go.

Dave:
I’m with you. I feel for everyone who works in the industry, if you’re dependent on transaction volume, if you’re an agent or a loan officer, it stinks right now. But I do think rather than a sharp correction, this is a tolerable solution even though it’s tough, it’s harder than it has been in quite a while.

Andy:
Yeah. I mean, the longer you live there, the more borrowers have higher rate loans. So if we see some reprieve, now you start to get that transaction volume that comes back from a refinance perspective as well. So it slowly builds and transitions over time.

Dave:
One thing you said about a similarity between now and great financial crisis was about equity positions, which I was kind of surprised by because my understanding is equity positions now are the best that they’ve ever been. Maybe that’s just in absolute dollars, but can you just explain a little bit more about that?

Andy:
Yeah. I mean, if you look at equity held by mortgage holders across the US, $17.5 trillion. So as you mentioned, if you just look in absolute dollars, we’re light years ahead of where we were in 2005 and 2006. What I really meant by that was CLTVs and the fact that when you see home prices peak, you’re at the peak of equity positions, right? So similar in that vein, but in terms of total dollars, you’re absolutely right. Record highs in terms of total dollar equity out there, again, 17.5 trillion for total equity. If we look at what’s called tappable equity, the amount that you could borrow against while still maintaining a 20% equity cushion in your home, 11.3 trillion right now, highest third quarter we’ve ever seen. Oh my God. Average mortgage holder has $204,000 in equity. We saw the number of equity millionaires hit an all-time high in the third quarter of this year as well.
So obviously that continued growth at the national level in terms of home prices just keeps stacking equity on top of these homeowners.

Dave:
Wow. No wonder people are pushing for that increase in the capital gains exclusion for primary residents if 2.4 million mortgage holders have at least a million dollars of equity in their home. That is a wild stat. How do you think, Andy, this very strong equity position by the average American homeowner plays out or sort of contributes to your view of what happens next in the housing market?

Andy:
I mean, I think when you look at it from a lender perspective, and I think this is where it becomes interesting with the low volume environment that you were talking about, I think both homeowners and lenders see that as an opportunity. Homeowners see it as a way of, okay, I can keep my low interest rate that I’ve locked in. I’m in a good position from a cash flow perspective. I can also start to utilize some of that equity that I have in my home. If I’m going to stay put a little bit longer, I can renovate, I can do things that I want to do with that equity. Lenders are seeing that as an opportunity to build some lending volume in a place where maybe they haven’t had as much over the last few years. And so you’re seeing more activity and more intent around that equity, both from a homeowner perspective and from a lending community just because of that record level of equity and because a lot of those homeowners want to hold onto those low rates that they’ve locked in in recent years.

Dave:
What about the other side?You’ve talked a lot about the strength of many homeowners, but from my understanding, the number of mortgages that are underwater is increasing. Can you tell us a little more about that?

Andy:
Yeah. I mean, it kind of speaks to that bifurcation that we’re seeing in the market of two thirds of markets are seeing prices continue to push higher, one third are seeing prices pull off of their peak. And if you look at the number of borrowers that are underwater right now, it’s up to about 2% right now. And it’s a really heavily centered population, both in terms of when folks bought their homes and where they bought their homes and in terms of what types of loans that they use to buy those homes. So close to 90% of those borrowers that are in a negative equity position bought since 2022 or took out their mortgage since 2022. So those folks that have bought out or near the peak of their local market, predominantly low down payment loans, so those FHA, VA, 0% down, 3.5% down type products.
And they’re largely centered in the Southern US. So Florida, certainly where you’ve seen some prices come off of their recent highs, Austin prices are down 23% from their peak. And so you’re seeing a pocket there around Austin and other parts of Texas. Seen a little bit of creeping in Colorado, around Denver and Colorado Springs where prices have softened a little bit as well. But then when you look at the rest of the country, it looks really strong. California next to nonexistent, Midwest, Northeastern US next to nonexistent. So again, to me, one, it’s again, largely a return to normalcy. That’s roughly what you saw in the mid 20 teens and early 2000s in terms of negative equity rates. So there’s some degree of normalization there and really a localized story in terms of things are very different in your Florida and Texas markets that have been softer than they are in other areas of the country.

Dave:
Is the percentage of mortgages underwater and/or the amount of distress like delinquencies in a regional market predictive in any way of the direction of prices?

Andy:
When you look at what it means, they kind of feed off of each other. It’s a little bit of a chicken and the egg type of dynamic of the reason that there are negative equity properties in the market is because home prices have already softened up a little bit. They can compound and feed off of each other in terms of overall home price growth. When you start to see distressed inventory, if they move forward to foreclosure sale, you can then see some distress that can result in some lower home prices in those particular markets as well. So they kind of feed on each other, but really you need softer home prices in the first place in order to get that negative equity into that market. And again, it’s really the combination of negative equity and delinquency as well. If you’re in a negative equity position, but your economy is strong and that borrower still has a job and the borrower still has cash flow, they continue to make mortgage payments on a home, even if they’re slightly underwater on that home.
When you have a borrower that’s delinquent and they don’t have equity to kind of sell out from under that home and reset themselves financially, that’s where it starts to limit borrowers options and you see more of that distress sale activity.

Dave:
We’ll be back with Andy right after this quick break. Welcome back to On the Market. Let’s get back to my conversation with Andy Walden. Well, this has been great, Andy. Just one last question for you. We’re sort of ending 2026, entering 2027. I won’t ask you to make a prediction, but I will ask you, what are some of the key metrics you think we as a real estate investing community should be watching as we head into 2027?

Andy:
If I’m an investor and I’m looking obviously at my local market or my local markets, supply is the key one in terms of where your market is going, where prices are about to trend. I mean, that’s been the key metric. A lot of folks would think that it’s home affordability and the market trying to normalize and bring itself back to normal. But if there isn’t enough supply there to allow the buy and sell sides to kind of transact the way that they want to, then prices continue to move higher. And we’ve seen that over the last couple of years in the Midwest and Northeastern regions of the country where you have some affordability challenges in some of those markets, but supply is just so shallow that it continues to push prices higher in the opposite in the south and west where that’s where new construction has started to come in and fill the void of those existing homeowners and rightsize that balance.
And that’s where you’re starting to see things soften up a little bit. So again, I would keep an eye on the supply side of the house, how much inventory is there in your market. You can measure it by days on market. I like to look at it by where are we versus where we traditionally are in this market? Where are we versus pre-pandemic levels of supply? That’s been a pretty good indicator of where your market’s about to go from a price perspective.

Dave:
Awesome. Well, Andy, thank you so much for joining us today. This was super informative. Any last thoughts or where people can learn more about you and what you’re doing with ICE?

Andy:
I think we touched on a lot. I mean, if you’re interested in hearing more, you can Google ICE Mortgage Monitor. We put out a monthly publication every month that talks about the latest mortgage performance trends, housing market dynamics, what’s going on inside of the mortgage market at any given point in time, along with local and national lending trends. So give that a Google if you’d like to learn more.

Dave:
Yeah, we will link to it in the show notes. It’s something I 100% look at every single month. It’s super valuable information, so definitely check it out. Thank you, Andy, and thank you all for watching this episode of On the Market. We’ll see you next time.

Help us reach new listeners on iTunes by leaving us a rating and review! It takes just 30 seconds and instructions can be found here. Thanks! We really appreciate it!

Interested in learning more about today’s sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Email [email protected].

Why Similarweb Stock Surged Today


Shares of Similarweb (SMWB +13.04%) climbed 13% on Tuesday after the data analytics provider reported strong gains in sales and profits.

Image source: Getty Images.

Similarweb has built an extensive data-gathering platform

The software company’s revenue rose 16% to $83 million in the third quarter.

Similarweb acts as a digital intelligence supplier to over 10,000 organizations around the world. Its ever-expanding data set spans more than 100 million websites, 4 million apps, and 235 million e-commerce products.

Demand for Similarweb’s insights is rising as competition within the digital economy intensifies. Customers generating annual recurring revenue (ARR) of $100,000 or more grew 6% to 474.

These customers are also spending more on Similarweb’s platform. Its dollar-based net retention rate (NRR) for clients with ARR of at least $100,000 increased to 114% from 105% in the prior-year period.

SMWB Similarweb

$8.84+$1.02 (+13.04%)

NYSE · As of 4:00 PM ET 11/17/26

Notably, artificial intelligence (AI)-powered offerings are helping to accelerate Similarweb’s growth. AI-related business accounted for approximately two-thirds of ARR added in the third quarter, according to chief financial officer Ran Vered.

Better still, Similarweb is growing more profitable as it scales its operations. Adjusted operating margin improved to 12% from 6% in the year-ago quarter. Adjusted net income, in turn, more than doubled to $9.4 million, or $0.10 per share.

Similarweb sees a long runway for expansion ahead

Management now expects full-year revenue to grow by roughly 13% to $319 million in 2026, resulting in adjusted operating profit of about $30 million.

“As AI takes on more of the analysis and action, the quality, breadth, and the freshness of the underlying data matter more, and that is where we remain special,” co-founder Or Offer said during a conference call with analysts.

Where to invest $1,000 right now

When our analyst team has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, Stock Advisor’s total average return is 802%* — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 205% for the S&P 500.

They just revealed what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy right now, available when you join Stock Advisor.

See the stocks ›

*Stock Advisor returns as of November 17, 2026.

Joe Tenebruso has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Hyatt and Delta Unveil Details on Their New Loyalty Collaboration


Hyatt and Delta Unveil Details on Their New Loyalty Collaboration

Hyatt and Delta revealed today more details on the previously announced partnership. Beginning today, elite members who link their accounts can earn rewards across both qualifying Delta flights and Hyatt stays, bringing one of the most requested loyalty benefits to life and giving travelers more value from the journeys they are already taking. Linked members will then be able to access limited-time offers, and eligible linked members in the U.S. can enter for the chance to win a trip through SkyMiles® Experiences, no points or miles required at Alila Mayakoba in Riviera Maya, Mexico.

Starting in 2027, eligible elite members of both programs will gain access to new milestone reward choices, giving them more ways to earn, more flexibility in how they use their loyalty and more possibilities for where their rewards can take them next.

Dual Earn Takes Flight

Elite members of both programs who link their Delta SkyMiles® and World of Hyatt accounts beginning today can earn rewards across both qualifying flights and stays.

In addition to earning Delta SkyMiles® under the Delta SkyMiles® program, linked World of Hyatt elite members can earn Bonus Points on eligible Delta flight fares, which include Delta Comfort, Delta Premium Select, Delta First Class and Delta One:

  • Discoverist members can earn one World of Hyatt Bonus Point for every $2 in eligible Delta flight spend.
  • Explorist, Globalist and Lifetime Globalist members can earn one World of Hyatt Bonus Point for every $1 in eligible Delta flight spend.

An “Eligible Flight” means a ticket on a fare class of Delta Comfort, Delta Premium Select, Delta First Class, or Delta One, on a flight marketed and operated by Delta (006 stock), but excluding (i) any complimentary upgrades to the listed cabins and (ii) award tickets.

Delta SkyMiles® Diamond, Platinum, Gold and Silver Medallion Members can earn one Delta mile for every $1 in qualifying spend at participating Hyatt properties in addition to earning World of Hyatt points under the World of Hyatt program. Eligible spend includes qualifying room rates, qualifying incidental spend, and qualifying non-stay charges at participating Hyatt properties, eligible Mr & Mrs Smith spend booked through Hyatt, and eligible spend at The Venetian booked through Hyatt.

More Rewards at More Milestones

The collaboration will also introduce new ways for qualifying members to choose rewards across both programs, helping them turn loyalty milestones into future flights, stays and experiences.

Beginning January 1, 2027, linked World of Hyatt members can choose from a range of Delta awards as they reach qualifying Milestone Rewards thresholds. The first Delta award choice will become available at 20 qualifying nights or 35,000 Base Points, with additional choices as members progress through the program, including:

  • Delta e-certificates in varying amounts at milestones from 20 to 60 qualifying nights
  • Two single visit Delta Sky Club passes at 70, 80 and 90 qualifying nights
  • Opportunities to receive Delta Medallion Status at milestones from 100 to 150 qualifying nights

Beginning February 1, 2027, with the start of the 2028 Medallion Year, qualifying Delta SkyMiles® members will also have new ways to turn their loyalty into memorable World of Hyatt stays. Through Delta Choice Benefits, eligible members can select World of Hyatt Free Night Awards, as a 2028 Medallion Year Choice Benefit, including:

  • A Category 1-4 Free Night Award as a Platinum Choice Benefit
  • A Category 1-7 Free Night Award as a Diamond Choice Benefit

These new choices extend the value of Delta loyalty across more of the travel journey, giving them more flexibility to select the rewards that best fit their travel goals.

Hyatt Delta partnership Details

Limited-Time Offers for Linked Members

To celebrate the start of this new chapter, Hyatt and Delta are introducing a series of limited-time offers for members who link their accounts.

From November 17 through December 31, 2026, linked members can register to earn one additional World of Hyatt Tier-Qualifying Night Credit after completing their first qualifying Hyatt stay during the offer period. 

The celebration continues in 2027. From January 4 through February 15, linked members can:

  • Earn 1,000 World of Hyatt Bonus Points after completing their first eligible Delta premium cabin flight following account linking. Eligible Delta premium cabin flight fares include Delta Comfort, Delta Premium Select, Delta First Class and Delta One
  • Earn 1,000 Delta miles after completing their first qualifying Hyatt stay following account linking

Together, the offers give linked members an immediate opportunity to begin experiencing the added value of the collaboration across both sides of their journey. In the future, linked members of both programs will be able to participate in status challenges to fast track to elite status. Further details to come.

See here for full terms of these offers.

Enter to Win an Unforgettable SkyMiles® Experience

Hyatt and Delta are also teaming up for an exclusive Delta SkyMiles® Group Drop Experience, giving members the chance to escape to Alila Mayakoba, part of Hyatt’s Luxury Portfolio, in Riviera Maya, Mexico, no points or miles required.

Invite a friend and enter together for the chance to win two $1,000 Delta Gift Cards to use towards airfare from their home airport to Cancun International Airport, a three-night stay at Alila Mayakoba for two from January 22 to January 25, 2027, food and beverage, choice of a complimentary wellness, fitness or culinary experience, access to an on-property Delta lounge pop-up and a special farewell dinner and concert.

From elevated travel and thoughtful hospitality to standout food, live music and Riviera Maya sunshine, the experience will bring the Hyatt and Delta collaboration to life in one memorable getaway.

Additionally, members who link their World of Hyatt and Delta SkyMiles® accounts before entering the sweepstakes will be eligible for one extra entry to win. Visit here for official rules and details to enter to win the SkyMiles® Experience, visit https://world.hyatt.com/content/gp/en/rewards/delta-skymiles.html to link accounts, and learn more about the new benefits.

Mortgage Rates in Limbo With Nvidia Earnings on Deck


Mortgage rates are flat today, still hovering around 7.50% for the average 30-year fixed.

The 10-year Treasury yield, which mortgage rates follow, remains around 5.10%, as October retail sales came in line with expectations.

But the bigger story won’t come until after the bell today, when Nvidia reports its third quarter earnings.

They are essentially the face of both the AI trade and the wider stock market, so what happens there could be a significant mortgage rate mover.

So if you’re watching rates and trying to decide whether to lock or float, keep a close eye on Nvidia.

Retail Sales Came in as Expected, But With Some Heat

The only biggish report today was October retail sales, which rose 0.2% as expected, a big slowdown from September’s 0.8% growth rate.

However, excluding the gas and auto categories, retail sales increased 0.6%, which was more than the 0.4% economists expected.

The data once again reinforces the need for the Fed to hike rates, at this point a foregone conclusion next month and perhaps even more after that.

The takeaway thus far is higher interest rates haven’t slowed down the consumer, and that’s a problem for anyone hoping for lower mortgage rates.

A cooler economy is one of the best ways to get mortgage rates to come down.

But economic report after economic report continues to work against that trend, whether it’s a strong jobs report, inflation report, or consumer spending.

That means we must look elsewhere for a path to lower mortgage rates.

Falling Tech Stocks the Only Thing Helping Mortgage Rates Lately

The Nasdaq fell as much as 300 points this morning, with chip stocks once again leading the way down.

There was news that the United States may limit third-country access to advanced AI chips, which could hurt growth.

If this continues, it could prompt another flight to safety in bonds, which increases bond prices and lowers associated bond yields.

That’s the simple way mortgage rates also move lower, as investors determine that bonds yielding 5-7% are a better investment than risky high-flying tech stocks.

Typically, money leaves stocks and some of it moves to Treasuries, pushing yields (and mortgage rates) down a bit.

It worked over the past month, but recently hasn’t been going as expected, with stocks falling while bond yields have increased (or barely budged lower).

We’re basically getting the worst of both worlds right now; lower stock prices, which wipe out perceived wealth, and higher interest rates.

Nvidia Earnings Could Swing Mortgage Rates Up or Down

While the stock to bond flight to safety has been a dud lately, Nvidia earnings could change all that.

The company reports after the market close today and it has the potential to solidify the recent move lower or lead to a stock market bounce.

The once-beloved stock (NASDAQ: NVDA) is down nearly 40% from its October high thanks in part to former CEO Jensen Huang’s resignation.

However, an earnings beat is widely expected today and if Nvidia delivers and tech rebounds, some of the recent safe-haven demand for bonds could fade away.

In the process, you could see yields could drift back up, and given they remain elevated despite Nvidia’s recent fall, it could be bad news for mortgage rates.

The 30-year fixed is only about 0.125% off its recent highs, while Nvidia is down nearly 40%. That doesn’t exactly tell you it’s been a major flight to safety.

Of course, mortgage spreads have also widened recently, which hurts mortgage rates even if bond yields remain static.

Now the counterpoint is if Nvidia’s results disappoint, bonds could see renewed demand and yields could plummet.

That could send mortgage rates meaningfully lower and reinforce a more lasting flight to safety in bonds.

In the process, the AI buildout that arguably pushed mortgage rates higher could begin to unravel.

But that’s just one of many drivers of mortgage rates to consider. We still have the Iran war, oil prices, inflation, labor, etc.

Read on: Compare mortgage rates and monthly payments side by side with my mortgage rate calculator.

Colin Robertson
Latest posts by Colin Robertson (see all)

Earnings call transcript: IRIDEX Q3 2026 misses estimates as shares sink 25%




Earnings call transcript: IRIDEX Q3 2026 misses estimates as shares sink 25%

Start Trading Crypto On Coinbase — Watch The Related Video Below. #trading #forextrading



Register –

Coinbase is hosting its first-ever, India exclusive trading competition. From Rolexes to a
Mini Cooper, compete to unlock up to ₹3.3 Crore in prizes. Trade futures on Coinbase
Advanced and dominate the arena across 3 leaderboards

Register before 7th July to participate in competition
Coinbase Champions Cup:

source

ABA Council Loosens Law School Accreditation Standards On Adjuncts, Classroom Credits, And Bachelor’s Degrees


Key Points
  • The ABA’s law school accreditation council voted November 13, 2026, to cut required classroom credits from 64 to 48 of the 83 credits needed to graduate.
  • The revised rules drop the first-year full-time teaching requirement and allow admission without a bachelor’s degree in an “appropriate case.”
  • Nothing takes effect until the ABA House of Delegates votes in February 2027, while the Education Department decides whether the council keeps its federal role.

The American Bar Association’s law school accreditation council voted to roll back several accreditation standards that every ABA-accredited law school must meet. The votes loosen rules on classroom credits, first-year teaching, and admission without a bachelor’s degree, Reuters reported.

The changes come months after new federal student loan caps for law students took effect impacting professional degrees like law.

The council acted on two recommendations from its Standards Committee: a memo on classroom credits and admissions (PDF File) and a second memo on faculty rules (PDF File). The rules apply to all 198 ABA-accredited law schools, where most students attend law school to attain their JD. Both sets of proposed changes now go to the ABA House of Delegates for its February 2027 Midyear Meeting, so none of them has taken effect yet.

Why It Matters

Federal borrowing for law school is now capped, which puts more weight on what schools charge. Since July 1, 2026, law students can borrow no more than $50,000 a year and $200,000 total in federal Direct Loans. New borrowers no longer have Grad PLUS loans to cover the rest.

Critics have argued that the council’s standards push up student costs without providing additional benefits. Adjunct professors typically cost less than full-time faculty, and the Standards Committee wrote that dropping the first-year teaching rule “would also potentially allow for greater use of adjunct faculty in teaching foundational courses.” That matters as schools absorb federal student loan limits that are already pressuring college budgets.

Council member José Roberto Juárez Jr., a former law dean at Nova Southeastern University, said the standards should pair rigorous oversight with “the flexibility to operate in the way that they deem best,” according to Reuters.

Supporters in the public comments (PDF File) called the changes a reasonable way to give schools flexibility, while one opponent warned they could devalue classroom instruction.

What The Council Changed

.tci-aba-std{font-family:inherit;border:2px solid #141414;border-radius:8px;overflow:hidden;margin:24px 0;color:#141414;background:#fff}.tci-aba-std .tci-aba-head{background:#141414;color:#fff;padding:14px 18px;font-size:18px;font-weight:700;line-height:1.3}.tci-aba-std .tci-aba-head span{color:#f6c061}.tci-aba-std table{width:100%;border-collapse:collapse;font-size:15px;margin:0}.tci-aba-std th{background:#f9f7f5;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:.04em;text-align:left;padding:10px 14px;border-bottom:1px solid #e5e0d8;color:#55504a}.tci-aba-std td{padding:12px 14px;border-bottom:1px solid #e5e0d8;vertical-align:top;line-height:1.45}.tci-aba-std tbody tr:nth-child(even){background:#fcfbf9}.tci-aba-std td.tci-aba-label{font-weight:700}.tci-aba-std .tci-aba-pill{display:inline-block;padding:2px 10px;border-radius:999px;font-size:12px;font-weight:700;white-space:nowrap}.tci-aba-std .tci-aba-loose{background:#f6c061;color:#141414}.tci-aba-std .tci-aba-same{background:#dff3e4;color:#14532d}.tci-aba-std .tci-aba-foot{background:#f9f7f5;padding:10px 18px;font-size:12px;color:#8a8378}@media (max-width:640px){.tci-aba-std thead{display:none}.tci-aba-std tr{display:block;border-bottom:1px solid #e5e0d8;padding:8px 0}.tci-aba-std td{display:block;border:0;padding:6px 14px}.tci-aba-std td[data-label]::before{content:attr(data-label);display:block;font-size:11px;text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:.04em;color:#8a8378;margin-bottom:2px}}

What The ABA Council Changed In November 2026
Rule Old Standard New Standard Status
Classroom Credits (Standard 311) 64 of 83 required credits 48 of 83 required credits Loosened
First-Year Teaching (Standard 403) Full-time faculty teach substantially all of the first third of coursework Requirement removed Loosened
Admission Without A Bachelor’s Degree (Standard 502) Only in an “extraordinary case” Allowed in an “appropriate case” Loosened
Faculty Size (Standard 402) Enough full-time faculty for teaching, research, governance and service Enough to “fulfill their professional obligations” Loosened
Full-Time Teaching Share (Standards 402 And 403) More than half of credit hours or two-thirds of contact hours No change Unchanged
Source: ABA Standards Committee. The College Investor.

Standard 311 still requires 83 credits to graduate. The old rule required 64 of those credits in regularly scheduled classes or direct faculty instruction. At 48 credits, that share drops to about 58%, which frees up to 35 credits for clinics, externships and field placements.

The Standards Committee said 48 credits equals a first-year curriculum plus a little more than one semester. It also said the lower number gives schools more room to design part-time programs. Part-time study lets working students keep earning, which can reduce what they need to borrow under the new graduate school student loan limits.

Standard 502 still expects a four-year degree, or three-fourths of the credits toward one, in most cases. The old exception applied only in an “extraordinary case.” The new language allows an “appropriate case” when an applicant’s experience, ability and other qualifications clearly show an aptitude for law.

One public comment in the credits and admissions memo (PDF File) flagged a catch. Students admitted without a degree may be barred from the bar exam in states that require an undergraduate degree. Check your state’s bar admission rules before you borrow student loans for a JD on that path.

Revised Standard 403 (PDF File) drops the requirement that full-time faculty teach “substantially all” of the first third of each student’s coursework. Revised Standard 402 asks for enough full-time faculty to “fulfill their professional obligations,” in place of a list of research, governance and service duties. The revised rules still require full-time faculty to teach more than half of credit hours or more than two-thirds of student contact hours.

Lower staffing costs matter more as colleges look to contain expenses.

What It Means For Law Students

A student who borrows the $50,000 federal maximum in each of three years leaves with $150,000 in federal student loans. Any cost above that line now comes from scholarships, savings or private student loans.

Nothing in the new standards requires schools to pass savings on to students. More adjunct teaching and off-campus credit could lower a school’s costs, but each school still sets its own tuition. Compare each school’s net price against the federal borrowing caps for professional students before you borrow.

Students weighing law school in 2027 or beyond should ask each school a few questions:

  • Which first-year courses will adjuncts teach after the new rules take effect?
  • How many of the 83 credits can come from field placements, externships or remote courses?
  • Does the bar in the state where you plan to practice require a bachelor’s degree?
  • What will the full cost of attendance be, and how much of it sits above the $50,000 annual federal cap?

The answers show whether a school plans to use the new flexibility to cut costs or to change how it teaches. Our list of the best law school student loans shows what borrowing past the federal cap would cost.

How This Connects

The votes land while the council fights to keep its federal role, part of the Education Department’s push to break up accreditor power.

In August, Education Department staff released an 86-page staff report (PDF File) recommending that the council lose federal recognition. The report found the council is not “separate and independent” from the larger ABA. An advisory committee could not agree on a recommendation in September, which left the decision to Under Secretary Nicholas Kent.

Law schools need accreditation from a federally recognized accreditor for students to receive federal financial aid, the ABA Journal noted. That ties the council’s fate to the student loans behind most JDs.

What’s Next

The ABA House of Delegates will review the changes at its Midyear Meeting in February 2027.

Kent’s decision on the council’s recognition is expected by the end of 2026. Further changes to Standard 402(b) will go back out for public comment. Students applying for fall 2027 should track both decisions alongside the $50,000 annual cap on federal student loans for law school.

Editor: Colin Graves

The post ABA Council Loosens Law School Accreditation Standards On Adjuncts, Classroom Credits, And Bachelor’s Degrees appeared first on The College Investor.

Amazon: Use Citi Thank You Points & Get 40% Off, Up To $50 Discount


Update 11/17/26: More targeted

Update 10/1/26: Deal is back and valid until December 31st, 2026, 5:00 PM PT. Share what deal you received in the comments below.

The Offer

Direct Link to offer (contains our affiliate link, thanks for your support)

  • Activate offer and get 40% off products on Amazon.com when you use Citi ThankYou points at checkout. Max discount $50. Valid through 12/31/26.

Key Details:

  • Must use a minimum of 125 points ($1). No need to pay for the entire purchase with points.
  • Does not seem to be working on gift cards this time around (2025). 
  • This does work for third-party sellers, e.g. items sold by third-party which are shipped by Amazon. (Does not need to be ‘shipped and sold by Amazon’.)
  • You should be able to use this on multiple small purchases until you exhaust the $50/$30 dollar limit.

 

Our Verdict

Nice to see the ThankYou version come back with excellent savings here. You can stack this with Cyber Monday deals on Amazon.

Try linking your Citi card and then check back after 24 hours to see if the offer shows. Also try unlinking and then relinking a couple days later and then check back to see if it shows up.

See this page for an updated list of all live Shop With Points deals, along with easy links to check.

Deal History:

  • Update 12/10/25: More targeted
  • Update 11/30/25: This deal has been gone for a few years and finally came back with 40% back, up to $50 discount. I got the 30%/$30 version. Updated below.
  • Update 11/6/22: More targeted, now it’s showing an end date of 11/30/22. (Chuck) I’m seeing the 30%/$15 version now.
  • Update 10/10/22: Deal is back and 40% off up to $30. Good until 12/31/2022.