No W-2? Why These Banks Still Say Yes! (Rookie Reply)

Date:

Share post:


Not having a W-2, trusting the wrong numbers, or feeling unprepared for closing day can stop a lot of new investors before they get started. But none of them have to! With the right questions and a little homework, you can find financing that fits your situation and step into your first deal with confidence!

Welcome back to another Rookie Reply! Today, Ashley and Tony are back answering more questions from the BiggerPockets Forums. We’re starting with a question plenty of self-employed investors ask: can you still buy a rental property without a steady paycheck? We walk through the loan options most rookies never hear about, from seller financing to the one type of lender that made both of our creative deals possible.

Next, we show you how to stop taking someone else’s word on after repair value (ARV). You’ll hear why you should run your own numbers first, followed by how pros actually value a property. Finally, we help a future landlord get ready to close on his first house hack, and Ashley makes the case for a move that could save him money from day one.

Ashley:
Today’s rookie reply is about being ready before the deal is yours. A pile of cash, a promising after repair value, or an accepted offer can each hide a different first investor risk.

Tony:
We have a freelance with capital, but uneven income, a buyer who wants to verify an agent’s ARV and a future house hacker with a fourplex in Washington.

Ashley:
This is the Real Estate Rookie Podcast. I’m Ashley Kehr.

Tony:
And I’m Tony J. Robinson. With that, let’s get into our first question of the day. So this question comes from Hima and Hema says, “Does anyone have suggestions for how I should move forward with no W-2?” So just some context here. Hema’s freelance income has been somewhat uneven, so she expects access to roughly 200 to 500K next summer and is considering a duplex to possibly a fourplex and maybe even outside of her current market. So she has hands-on renovation and property managed experience, but wonders how to prepare when she may not even yet have a long W-2 history or a local team. All right, so this is basically like a financing question of how do I get financed when I don’t have steady income? First thing I’ll say is that there is a loan product for everyone out there. And I say this often in the podcast, but think about the mortgage industry in the same way you think about the ice cream industry where I can go to Baskin-Robbins, I can go to Ben & Jerry’s, name your favorite ice cream, and they all sell the same product.
I can get ice cream in each place, but they’re slightly different flavors. I can’t get, I don’t know, Ash, do you have a favorite Ben & Jerry’s flavor, chunky monkey? I’m trying to think of one. I don’t even know if that’s real, but I can’t go to Baskin Robbins and get Ben & Jerry’s. It’s the same thing for the lending industry where every lender sells a mortgage. They all sell the same end result, but the flavor and how they execute and where they specialize, that’s always different. And you can take a deal, you can take a borrower to three different lenders and get three totally different answers. The first person might look at you and say, “There’s no way anyone’s ever going to give you a loan.” The second person might say, “Oh, we write these kind of loans all day, every day.” In fact, I just did three this morning.
And the third person might say, “I honestly don’t even know what to do with your situation because I’ve never seen it before.” So it depends on who you go talk to. So my first and most important advice, Hima, is to go talk to as many lenders as you possibly can, especially those who specialize in working with folks who have 1099 income, who are self-employed, who don’t have a traditional W2 and steady paycheck to bank on. And I guarantee those options are out there.

Ashley:
One thing that you can look into specifically is a DSCR loan. So with a DSCR loan, they’re actually looking at the property instead of you specifically. So I would definitely do Tony’s step first, see what products they have available, what they can offer you, but also if that ends up being a dead end, but I think some will come to you with the DSER option anyways, is they’re going to look at the property and make sure that the income from the property can actually support the mortgage payment and other monthly expenses, and they’re going to care about that more than what your income looks like, what your debt to income looks like. So right there is a first option. The second thing you can do is look at commercial lending. Now, I can’t remember, did they were going to live in this house or was it just going to be an investment property?

Tony:
I don’t think she specified.

Ashley:
Okay. So if it’s just going to be investment only and you’re not going to live in the property, you could go to the commercial side of lending. So go to small local banks in the area and tell them you want to talk to the commercial lender. It’s not as great of financing as you would get on the residential side, but if this is the only way that you can actually get into a deal and they kind of work similar to a DSER loan, they want to look at your experience will pull a lot of weight when they’re overlooking or looking at you for a loan, but also they’ll look at the performance of the actual property too, instead of as heavily on you personally as a lot of other loan products do. Then we just did a full episode on seller financing. So going out and looking for sellers that would actually hold the financing for you and you would actually make them payments directly instead of paying a bank is another option you can do too.

Tony:
And Ash, even for me personally, we just bought a new primary, so we had to go through this loan process and this is my first time buying a primary residence, not having W2 income because when bought our first primary, I hadn’t even bought my first rental yet. So my life has changed dramatically since we bought our first primary and we use what’s called a bank statement loan because I don’t have super sexy W2 income. The best way for me to get qualified was to do a bank statement loan. And so like guys, there are so many options out there and you won’t know until you go talk to enough lenders. So Ash and I say this a lot is that as you’re shopping for a loan product, don’t necessarily go to the lender or go to the credit union or go to the bank and say, “Hey, can I get a 20% down investment loan?” Say, “Hey, I’ve got about this much capital.
Here’s the type of property or style of property that I’m looking for. Here’s what my execution plan is. I want to buy it, do some renovations.” What’s the best loan product you have for that type of situation? So describe your situation, describe your goals, and then put it on the lenders to go source the right loan product for you. And I found that that generally gives people or gives the lenders on the other side maybe a better opportunity to pair you with the right loan. Ash, I love your story and we talked about a lot in the podcast, but I love your story about the line of credit whole situation that you did. For rookies who haven’t heard that story yet, can you give us the breakdown of this creative financing that was the lender’s idea to help you buy that property?

Ashley:
Yeah. So my friend and I had bought one property together and then we decided we wanted to buy another one and ended up same street right down the road and we’re like, “We want this. Let’s make a look at it.” We looked at it like, “Let’s make an offer.” We made an offer. Is it accepted? And then we looked at each other like, “How are we going to pay for this?” And we ended up finding a private money lender and we’re like, “We’ll maybe talk with him and figure that out.” At the same time, we were going to the bank to do a line of credit. We were each getting lines of credit on other investment properties that we had, and we’re going and closing at the same time. And so we’re telling the lender about this deal. We just found it so great. And I even had with me the BiggerPockets calculator reports printed out and I showed him whatever and he was like, “Well, let me know what interest rate that private money lender because I can probably beat it and do a deal with you.” So I was like, “Oh, okay.” So I asked some more and what he ended up doing was a 90-day unsecured loan, so there’s no collateral on this loan.
And they lended me the exact amount that I would need to close on the property. So whatever the amount was I needed to send a check into closing to purchase this property in cash, that was the amount they were lending me. So they wrote me a check, I paid on closing day, and part of the agreement was I would go and refinance with long-term debt with the same bank. So we closed on the property, we put a fridge in the property, we got it appraised, it appraised for a lot more than what we actually purchased it for. And we were able to actually walk away with $2,500 each in our pockets because we were able to refinance, I think it was 70 or 75% of whatever the appraised value was. And that ended up that 70% ended up being more than what we actually purchased the property for.
So we got to put that money into our pockets and then the 90-day secured loan was paid off with the rest of the fund. So you never know what is available, all of these quirky different things, especially those small local banks too, as the different things they’re able to do with getting approvals in-house and things like that. This bank I think only has maybe six branches in total and I still work with them today too.

Tony:
Last thing I’ll share as because I just love sharing the story of my first deal as well because it was a very kind of creative financing, but the very first real estate investment deal I ever did, it was a long distance burr. So I was buying an older property. It was like a 1950s build, hadn’t really been touched since. It was in good condition, but needed a full, mostly cosmetic renovation. And there was a bank in that town in Shreveport, Louisiana where I was investing where they said, “Hey Tony, if you find a property where the purchase price plus all of your renovation costs put all that together, if that’s 70% or less of your after repair value, we’ll actually fund the entire deal for you.” So I was able to get into my first investment property with literally $0 out of pocket. I paid for an inspection.
I think I had to pay for the appraisal. It’s literally a couple hundred bucks out of pocket and I was able to control this asset. And now would Bank of America offer that same loan? Would Chase offer that same loan? Probably not, but these small local banks and have a lot more flexibility as well. So that’s why we always say, “Hey, go talk to the folks who are already lending in your area. Ash said, the same bank who had the loan for the property down the road was one who gave her this creative strategy for this new one. So start local, start small, and those folks tend to have sometimes the best options for you.

Ashley:
Next, an agent’s rosie after repair value looks like a deal until you test the comparable sales yourself. We’ll show you what a rookie can verify. Hima needs a financing plan before she shops seriously. Elliot’s question is about the other number that can make or break an offer. What is the property actually worth after the work? So here’s Elliot’s question. I’m curious how many people estimate ARB. Obviously agents can provide an ARV, but I’ve noticed some fairly wide discrepancies. I would like to be able to do some of my own math rather than just trust agents who I haven’t worked with in the past, and therefore I don’t know how accurate their estimates turn out to be, especially on off-market properties that an agent brings to me. They may be representing the seller too and have an extra incentive to present an ARB on the higher end, and I can’t necessarily go and ask another agent to calculate ARB for me when they wouldn’t be involved in the deal.
Not trying to sound cynical, just trying to do my due diligence. Okay, great question. And 100%, you are on the right page. You should be doing your own due diligence and you should be verifying numbers. Someone could be an expert at this, but you really don’t have any way of knowing that unless you actually verify the information that they are giving you. I’ve worked with a lot of agents and some know a lot about investing in real estate. Some just think this would be a great deal because they sell a lot of houses in this neighborhood and so they think just like they know a lot of people would want to live there, but they don’t actually know the numbers to actually back it up. So I think one of the best things you can do is get out the BiggerPockets calculator reports and pull your own numbers first.
Don’t even look at the data, the information they’re giving you. Pull out your numbers. Where will you get the insurance costs? Where will you pull the property taxes? Things like that. Then take what you have built and compare it with what they have sent you. And if there is a discrepancy, ask them, “Where did you get this number from? I couldn’t find that the property taxes were this or that my insurance costs would be this.” And maybe they can actually explain it to you as in this is where I got it from and maybe they’re correct and you were wrong. And that’s also a great way for you to learn for free too. So that’s what I would do is I would go out and verify all your numbers. I would find out the information yourself and then verify it with what they are telling you.
And if it’s more market specific than the actual deal, just do your market research with AI, have it help you, guide you, and then whatever the agents are telling you, have AI pull up data to actually back what they are saying. So if they’re telling you this is a great neighborhood because it has the number one school, put that into AI, say, “Hey, an agent told me that this neighborhood has the number one school. Can you tell me all the data and stats that you actually have on the school districts in this area? And is it actually a top school and why is it a top school?” So that’s just one example of what you can do.

Tony:
And Ash, I love your example of using AI because you’re asking it a very specific question. What are the school ratings and what’s the data behind that? What I wouldn’t do is go to ChatGPT, Claude, like Gemini name your tool and say, “Hey, what’s the ARV of this property?” Because that’s generally not going to be all that accurate. I agree with you completely though, Ash, about going through and building out your own after repair value and not relying on the agent. Same thing goes like a wholesaler. Never trust a wholesaler’s ARV because they’re usually very optimistic. One of the best things I found though to help me get a better sense of how to actually put my after repair value together is by seeing actual appraisals from that market. So I talked before, we were looking at properties in Oklahoma, gosh, I guess two summers ago now.
And one of the first things I did is I asked the agent I was working with, her name’s Laura White, and I said, “Hey Laura, can you just send me some recently done appraisals?” And she blacked out all the information so I couldn’t necessarily anything that was personal, but I was able to see how are the appraisers evaluating changes in square footage, changes in lot size, changes in condition, what’s the price per square foot that I’m seeing for the type of property that will end up what the property will look like once the repairs are done? And that gives you a really, really solid process for understanding how to come up with your ARV. And I can say, okay, well, if I have a 3-1 and the comps are a 3-2, well, how much did this other appraisal give for being short of bathroom or whatever it may be?
And then I can apply that to my property. Or then I can say, hey, if I spend X to get a bathroom, then I should get Y back on the back end on the appraised value. So what Ashley described was the importance of going to do it, but when you can see the appraisals, that gives you the tools and the mechanisms to know how do you actually make those adjustments based on how your property compares to the different comparables. So favorite thing to do is go get an appraisal. All right. Our last investor’s already made an offer on a fourplex, but what needs to be verified before the keys and tenant relationships transfer over? We’ll cover that right after a quick break. All right. Lawrence Green is nearing his four unit purchase in DC, and he plans to live in one unit and house act by renting out the others and hire a property manager.
So here’s his question. I’m based in DC and I’m working toward building a long-term multifamily real estate portfolio. I recently put an offer on a four-unit property, so I’m getting closer to taking my first steps as a landlord. My strategy is to live in one unit and rent out the others to help offset my housing costs while building equity. I’m focused on making smart purchases, maintaining healthy cash reserves, and growing sustainably over time. I do plan to use professional property manager rather than handle all the day-to-day operations myself. I’m joining BiggerPockets to learn from experienced investors, make connections and get better at analyzing deals and managing rental properties. But for those of you who’ve gone through this process, what should I be doing now to make the transition from prospective buyer to first-time landlord as smooth as possible? I’m especially interested in advice on preparing for closing, setting up finances and bookkeeping, choosing a property manager, building reserves, and avoiding common first-time rookie mistakes.
Awesome. Well, Lawrence, I think the first thing I’ll say is that you going into the forum and asking this question is one of the best ways to avoid common rookie mistakes is jumping in and not asking these questions. But maybe we can talk about pre-close or maybe during the closing process while you’re under contract and what happens immediately afterwards. Let’s say you do get an offer accepted, and this is assuming that you did your analysis and you underwrote the deal thoroughly and you feel confident it’s the right deal for you. During your due diligence period, the things that are most important to me that I would focus on are number one, finding the right property manager. I like making sure you have that piece down. Then ideally, I want that done before I even submit the offer, but getting a really good property manager, then doing all of your due diligence on the property itself.
So obviously getting a very thorough inspection report completed, seeing what actually comes back on the inspection report, and if you need to go get specialists like a roofer or an electrician or a plumber, a foundation expert, mold remediation, whatever it may be, go back and get those experts to come in, double check and make sure that everything’s solid. And then if there are anything of note, anything of importance that comes back, working with the seller to either A, get those things corrected before you move in, or B, giving you some sort of seller credit or money back to get those repairs completed yourself. So that’s what I’d be focused on during the escrow period, the closing period. Anything else, Ash, on your side for the actual closing timeframe?

Ashley:
Yeah, I think just if you’re using an agent, it’s so much easier to have them help you guide it through in New York State. We have attorneys that have all of that, but if you go to biggerpockets.com/resources, we also have an acquisition guide that helps you go through this whole process and what you need to do when you’re under contract and then what you need to do for closing. It’s like a template checklist. It’s free to download and you can go ahead and download that for that portion of things. And it’s super helpful to make sure that you create yourself some kind of template or checklist so that when you go ahead and repeat this, when you close on your next property or your next property, you have all of these steps that you know you need to repeatedly do over and over again each time and you can always add to it or change things.
As the property differs, you’ll realize there’s other things that you need to add to this checklist to have it grow over time.

Tony:
Ash, what do you think? I mean, because Lawrence also said he’s going to be house hacking, but he also plans to hire a property manager. What’s your take on that stance from Lawrence?

Ashley:
In my personal opinion, I think that you could easily self-manage. I think that it’s going to end up because you live there, and especially if the tenants know that you own the property, they’re just going to come to you anyways and cut out to the middleman, and then you’re paying a property manager a percentage to basically not even have them involved because your tenants are going to come right to you or basically to play telephone where your telephone tells the property manager and then it comes back to you for something for you to do that you’re already there. If you want a property manager because you don’t think that you will have time, you will be able to set up systems and processes and it’s going to be the easiest for you to be the property manager actually living in the property and you’ll be able to save more money for your next deal.
I would recommend self-managing. I would set up something like TurboTenant or RentReady as your property management software, do your lease agreement through there, have your tenants pay online. You can still have them submit formal maintenance requests through TurboTenant from their tenant portal or even RentReady or whatever software you decide to choose. So you still have a record, a log of everything. The only step would be is that you would need to go out and hire the contractor or the vendor. But Tony and I were talking about this today is that you have AI assistance now with Dots or Crockbot that can actually even go and do that for you, that you don’t even have to do that. And then you just hit an approval as to like, okay, I’ve got Joe Plumbing coming to the property, their rate is $79 for a service call and they know to call you to approve any kind of repair before they actually go ahead and do it.
And it is set for four o’clock on Monday and the tenant has been notified that they will be arriving. So now you can even eliminate that step of things with AI agents. So I would recommend looking into self-managing for yourself instead of hiring a property management company.

Tony:
Ash, can I give a wild real estate take right now? I think that every investor should buy short-term rental just to get over the fear of management because once you self-manage a short-term rental, I think going back to a long-term feels like so much easier. I shared on the podcast, our old primary, we turned that into a long-term rental. We haven’t had long-term rental in probably five years now. And we decide to self-manage. Hey, I had a property manage when I did my first long-term rentals as well, but we were like, “Hey, we’ve done enough.” Ashley helped me out a lot. I used TurboTenant, which was great. And basically we found a tenant, did all those things. But I bring this up, Ash, because we’re doing the walkthrough with the tenant when they move in. And in California, it just actually passed where you have to offer to supply a refrigerator to your tenants.
And we hadn’t talked about that before. I was like, “Hey guys, I’m super happy to go pick up a fridge for you guys today, but we’ll get it installed, or do you want to bring your own fridge?” And the husband and wife looked at each other like, “I think we’ll just buy our own.” Okay. All right, great. There was a crazy… We never get hail in Southern California, but literally two days before they moved in, there was this big hail storm and we had all these string lights in our backyard and the hail just destroyed the string lights and they were hanging off. I was like, “Hey guys, with the storm, we didn’t have a chance to fix those.” I was like, “I’ll send someone over to get a fix for you guys.” And they were like, “Oh, no, no, don’t worry about it. We’ll go there.
We’ll take care of it ourselves.” I couldn’t imagine having a short-term rental guest who was like, “I’ll take care of that myself.” So to hear those words coming from the person who’s paying to stay at the property, it’s like my mind is blowing. I’m like, “Is this how it’s always going to be?” They’re just like, “I’ll take care of it. I’ll handle it.” So maybe we’re in the honeymoon phase right now, but that’s my take is that I think everyone should start by managing a short-term rental because in the fear of managing the long-term rental, I think it just kind of melts away.

Ashley:
Tony, you’re so optimistic. Every landlord that’s listening to you right now is saying, “Well, obviously they don’t want you coming back to the property when they’re damaging it, doing illegal activity and just trashing the place.” So yeah.

Tony:
Try to keep me out, right?

Ashley:
It’s funny because how you say that going from short-term to long-term, I’ve also seen it the other way, and this is something from you and Sarah. I remember this one time she was just having difficulty with a guest that was just giving her a hard time and you told her something like, “Just tell them to leave. It’s our property. Just tell them to leave. We’ll be done with it. It’ll be done and over.” And then that’s it. And I think about that on the short-term rental side is that is a really nice thing about short-term rentals is they leave and you never have to talk to them again. Where a tenant, you’re stuck in an eviction that can last six months or longer like my last one did. But yeah, so there’s definitely pros and cons to both, but I just had to share that because that’s something that always sticks with me as a benefit of short-term rentals.
But you’re right about the difference of expectations, I guess. But it really depends on the tenant and the guests too. So it’s not really the strategy.

Tony:
I will say, Ashley, even a bad tenant, even if they’re only there for four days, those are the longest four days of our lives. It’s like, oh my God. Is it Friday? When are these people leaving? But yeah, pros and cons to each one. Pros and cons.

Ashley:
Well, thank you guys so much for joining us and let us know if you’re watching on YouTube in the comments, what do you prefer? Do you prefer an Airbnb guest or do you prefer a long-term tenant in your property? I’m curious to see. I’m Ashley, he’s Tony, and we’ll see you guys on the next episode.

Help us reach new listeners on iTunes by leaving us a rating and review! It takes just 30 seconds and instructions can be found here. Thanks! We really appreciate it!

Interested in learning more about today’s sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Email [email protected].

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related articles

Why AI Is Making Content Marketing Faster, Not Better

Why AI Is Making Content Marketing Faster, Not Better written by John Jantsch read more at Duct...

OSFI eases rules for smaller lenders to boost competition

Canada’s banking regulator is proposing lower capital requirements and cheaper funding options for smaller lenders in a...

Anthropic’s IPO is a bellwether—and a warning

Good morning. Anthropic just pulled off a record-breaking IPO, with the five-year-old company debuting at a value...