Why One Better Rental Beats Several Cheap Ones (Rookie Reply)

Date:

Share post:


Is a cheap rental really the safest way to start, or does it just trade one risk for another? Plenty of new investors are asking the same question, especially when buying a rental property in their own market feels out of reach.

Welcome back to another Rookie Reply! Today, a house hacker earning $20 an hour has saved enough to buy his next deal without a mortgage, but only in a low-cost, Section 8, D-class area. Ashley also started out buying cheap duplexes, so she knows exactly what this path looks like! She shares the cash flow wins, the hidden headaches nobody warns you about, and the one move she wishes she’d made instead.

You’ll also hear how to budget for one of the most expensive systems in any older rental, and how a paid-off home can become the first step toward a portfolio that replaces your income! Plus, Ashley breaks down the long-game wealth-building moves most rookie investors forget to plan for!

Ashley Kehr:
Today’s rookie reply is about being ready before the deal is yours. A pile of cash, a promising after repair value, or an accepted offer can each hide a different first investor risk. We have a freelancer with capital, but uneven income, a buyer who wants to verify an agent’s ARV and a future house hacker with a fourplex offer in Washington DC. This is The Real Estate Rookie Podcast. I’m Ashley Kare. And sadly, I am not joined by my co-host, Tony J. Robinson today, but he will be back for another episode. So let’s jump into our first question today. So got it pulled up here and our first one comes from Mike Carter in the BiggerPockets Forums. And his question is, “How do you budget for HVAC and duct maintenance on older rental properties?” Ooh, this is a great one because replacing an HVAC and especially the duct work can be very, very expensive, especially if you don’t take care of it.
Something that I did not even realize was part of the maintenance of an HVAC. I bought a rental before I even had my own home, so I didn’t know anything about HVAC and having to replace the filters. So three months, some six months maybe, but the filter needs to be replaced. And if you’re not maintaining that, then you’re just going to lessen the life of your HVAC system. So the first thing, find out what the cost is of those filters. So you’re going to know right there, you need to pay that every three months or however often your filter needs to be replaced in the HVAC. There are companies that offer a tune-up every year. I don’t do it, but you can do it. And it’s like at $99 and they’ll come out each year, they’ll check it, everything like that. I did just have all of my duct work clean because we had some of the flooring redone and some of the dust and whatever.
Long story short, it was not up to my standards of clean and they want to breathe in that dust. So we had the actual duct work and all the air vents cleaned out and that cost about, I think it was like $1,700 to do that. I did get a quote from another company. Their quote was $3,500. So it can contrast very differently, but that is recommended that you do that. They told me every four to five years that you have someone and come in and clean out the duct work. So those are two maintenance things that you can do. Also that third one of the tuneup for your maintenance too. Now, when you perform this maintenance, you’re just going to extend the life of your property and extend the life of your HVAC system. I just did a brand new HVAC system and it was around $18,000 for the system and the duct work.
And it was like a smaller property. So replacing the whole HVAC system can run at least $10,000, sometimes a little bit less maybe depending if you need a smaller unit, but this is something that you could get a quote for now. You could have somebody come into your home and quote the replacement of it so you have an idea. Yes, things increase, things go up. But if you’re purchasing this property and you have the home inspector come in, you can also have an HVAC technician come in and check it over and tell you, “These are the maintenance items that I would want you to do on it. This is the expected life of it that I think that it will have.” And then you can go ahead and kind of use that numbers like, “Okay, I know that I need to have X amount of reserves because in five years I may have to replace this HVAC system.” So I’m selling a rental property and the people that are buying it, they did.
They had an HVAC inspector come in and check the HVAC and they told us upfront, “We’re not asking for any repairs or anything like that or you to replace the unit. We just want to know ahead of time how long we actually have with it before we would need to replace it.” So I think that’s a really good idea. You can also have the hot water tank check too. Okay. Coming up, we have a house hacker who wants to buy a rental property in cash. You won’t want to miss this question. We’ll be right back. Okay, and welcome back. We just had a question from Mike about how to estimate an HVAC system. Now we’re going to go into question two. So this question, again from the BiggerPockets forums, and this question is from Jalen Warner. “So I currently have a duplex that I have house hacked and I’m looking for another deal.
However, I’m looking to pay all cash for it because I don’t want to over leverage myself and an all cash deal would serve as a cashflow investment. Now, granted, I don’t make a lot of money. I worked really, really hard to get to where I’m at now. I do security and I get paid $20 an hour, so I don’t necessarily have a lot of money, but I’m good at saving at least what I can. With this being said, I don’t see me paying all cash for a DFW deal. Our market is just too much for me and that’s a Dallas Fort Worth area. So he’s saying that it’s an inexpensive market and he wouldn’t be able to cover something in cash for that. So here’s what he’s thinking. Thinking of buying a property in Wichita Falls or Sherman Dennison area. He believes Sherman and Denison is a better market.
However, they cost a bit more and deals are far and few under 50,000 there. In Wichita Falls, you can find these deals. Yes, they are in low income areas, a lot of the D class areas, but I would be able to pay cash for it. The idea is to buy one cheaply, fix it up and rent it to Section eight or group home housing for steady income. Also use federal home programs like HOME, CDGB and AHP. I actually don’t know the last two there. I know the stigma around these areas like don’t invest and buy the block, but like I said, I make $20 an hour. I watched this one BiggerPockets episode that said to get in where you fit in, and that’s how I’m looking at it. I do realize when buying said asset, there is no real exit strategy. Honestly, I would look to hold it through.
Typical home buyers wouldn’t want to buy in areas like this and experienced investors probably have bigger fish to pry. So the only way I see me getting rid of this type of asset in any case I need to would be to sell to another investor like me. I know I’m not the first to think of this idea nor the last, but insight from you guys would be great. Whether you have done it or not, would love to hear if you have and if you continue to do so and what’s your strategy and if you have a plan out. Great question because this is how I got started. I bought these dumpy little duplexes for like $20,000 and there’s pros and cons. I was able to scale quickly because I was buying them cheaply.
They cash flowed great because I could buy them in cash like Jalen would. Also because the rent to price ratio was great. Even though I was buying a property at $20,000, the units were still renting for $1,500 each unit. And I do have some regrets though. I wish I wouldn’t have bought as many. So hear me out. In these declass areas, I have found that there’s more turnover. The properties have never really been as well taken care of. So you’re buying properties that most often are just bandaid after bandaid with never having any real solution or fix to them. So you’re constantly dealing with repairs and maintenance. Even though it’s painted, maybe it even has LVP flooring in it, there are still a lot of issues that came up for me in these properties behind the walls because the plumbing was never fully updated. The electric was never fully updated because they are these cheap properties that for somebody to come in and to dump $100,000 into a full renovation, they can never charge as much rent as they would need to get to make it worthwhile to do that full rehab.
So I got very lucky with mine. I ended up selling all of mine except for one. I still have one of them. I guess three, but two I am going to keep for a while. But the properties, my timing was just really great, let’s say that. Bought them in 2017, 2018, and then I sold them at the height of the market during COVID. So it was great. I sold some of them for like $60,000 and I bought them for 20. That is not always the case. You can’t always predict the market. So in Jaylen’s example here, I think your idea of buying a property in all cash is great. Reduce your risk. Don’t over leverage yourself, especially if you’re not making a ton of money at your W-2 income where if you have a vacancy or anything like that, that you’re not able to cover the mortgage payment or expenses or worst enough, you’re going through an eviction and can’t cover those expenses with your W-2, now you don’t have a mortgage to worry about.
Yeah, you’ll step to pay insurance, property taxes, things like that, but it really does reduce the burden on you if you have to cover the payments on that property. So I really love the idea that you are motivated enough to save enough cash to purchase a property and to buy it in all cash and to buy one instead of taking that down payment and spreading it out upon several and getting financing on them. The one thing that I will say is I do regret that I didn’t take all of that and just buy one better property. So I would challenge you, Jalen, to think about that as to how much longer would it take you to save up for a property, maybe putting down a bigger down payment, maybe not 20%, but maybe like 40%, 50% where it still reduces your risk enough. But all of the properties that I bought in better areas, better condition, in the long run, those were better properties for me.
So my headaches were just bandaid repairs, bandaid repairs, troubles with turnovers, hard to find good tenants, things like that. If you think you can overcome those issues and those problems that I had, then yes, this is probably a great avenue for you to start with. It obviously worked out for me, worked out good. So no, I don’t fully regret it, but I just like the properties now down the road that weren’t those $20,000 cheap duplexes. So definitely on the right path and having $50,000 in cash to buy a house and trying to decide what to do is a great position to actually be in. So we’re going to take a short break. And before we go, I just want to thank you guys so much for taking the time to check out our show sponsors and we’ll be right back with our last question.
Okay. Welcome back. Our last question is from Steven today and he actually inherited a home, moved into it, but now he’s looking to rent it out. So let’s take a look. Hello everyone. I’m 31 years old. I inherited my parents’ paid off home at 26. Lived in it a few more years and a year ago I got married and bought a house closer to my wife’s work. Now that we’ve had a baby, I’m going to rent my old house out. I already have my first tenant lined up and I’m doing a deep clean on the house right now. My long-term plan is to show a few years worth of positive cash flow on the books before buying my second door. In 20 years, I’d like to have enough rental properties to make this my sole income. So what should I do? Thanks. So Steven, that’s great.
You’re starting to think about down the road and in 20 years you want to be work optional with these properties and completely live off them. So a standard method to do is to figure out, okay, how much can I cash flow per property and then divide that by how much I need to live on a month? And that will tell you how many doors you need. But there is a problem with that. It doesn’t factor in into 20 years from now. So you could put your, if you’re buying more properties, you could put them on a 20 year amortization so you know in 20 years they’re going to be paid off. So every year you’ll have, if you buy one property a year, you buy one property every three years, you’re going to have a paid off property then after that 20 year mark every three years, which is just going to increase, increase, increase your cash flow.
Most people like the 30 year amortization because you cash flow more on day one. So my first step for you is you have this first property, you’re renting it out, is to start saving for the next one. Start saving for your down payment. Then you’re going to start researching what areas you want to be in. You’re going to put your 20%, maybe even 30% down. If you have a three year timeline, save up as much as you can, make sure you have reserves in place, then go out and buy the next one. Then three more years, go out and buy another one. The thing that a lot of people don’t calculate it is they’ll calculate, okay, my first properties, that one’s paid off. So let’s say you’re cash flowing a thousand dollars on that one. The next one, let’s say it’s 500 and then another 500 and then another 500.
Down the road, when you look back even 10 years, not even 20 years, you’re going to have built up a ton of equity in those properties where you can start taking the equity out of one property to fund another property. You can start saving up that cash flow to fund the down payments on your deals. Your rent is most likely going to continue to an increase every single year, or if not every year, every couple years, every three years, you’ll be able to increase the rent. And yes, your property taxes and your insurance will go up, but the idea is that your rent will always cover that or increase more than what your property taxes and insurance are. You should always be increasing if you are seeing a large increase in your property taxes and insurance. And then you’re going to look back and be like, oh my God, I have $100,000 in equity in this house from appreciation.
If you do put mortgages on the other properties, that’s your mortgage pay down that your tenant paid down. So in 20 years, you may be having enough cash flow to cover your properties, but you also might have enough equity to say, okay, now for the next 20 years, let’s say you accumulate 10 properties over 20 years, you hit that 20 year mark and you’re like, okay, I got enough cash flow. I’m good. Then what you could do is the next 20 years, sell a property every two years. With the equity that you have built up, you could say, okay, I’m selling this property for $200,000. I owe nothing. It’s paid off. I’m getting another $100,000 year 21, and then I’m going to have another hundred of that 200 left for year 22, then sell another property. You can do that. Obviously you’ll be taxed on these because they’re investments.
They’re not your primary home or anything like that. So you will need to talk to a tax advisor as to the best way to do that, but that’s just an additional option. You don’t have to sell them, but that’s just another way. Or you could go and refinance them, refinance, put the mortgage back on them, pull that cash out and use that. I like the idea of having paid off properties compared to doing it that way, but you could also go and do a line of credits, things like that. So the huge benefit of real estate investing is financial opportunities. Investing in real estate gives you multiple ways to find money and to pull money. And that is one of the best benefits I think of it, along with the tax advantages, having control of your own assets, and then just kind of building the life that you want because of the wealth that you’re creating with real estate.
Well, thank you guys so much for joining me today, and I promise Tony will be back and we’ll see you guys next time.

 

Help us reach new listeners on iTunes by leaving us a rating and review! It takes just 30 seconds and instructions can be found here. Thanks! We really appreciate it!

Interested in learning more about today’s sponsors or becoming a BiggerPockets partner yourself? Email [email protected].

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related articles

Turkish Airlines Chase Offer: Spend $1,000 and Get $50 Back

Turkish Airlines Chase Offer Chase has a new targeted offer for Turkish Airlines that can save you money...

Going Back to the Basics Is a Sign of Growth — Not Regression

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own. Key Takeaways Complexity is often where we go to feel safe....

What a tiny chorus of the ‘Bring Back Jensen’ tech bros gets wrong

A small band of rogue tech bros has ridden to Jensen Huang’s defense amidst a report from...

Bowman seeks bank input on plan to restructure supervision

The Federal Reserve’s top regulator said she hopes to install new regional supervisory directors in the “coming...